Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon

Luigis Mansion Dark Moon Banner

Luigi has strangely found his niche in the Mario universe as the ghostbusting, mansion tip-toeing brother. Why Nintendo and Shigeru Miyamoto decided to make a GameCube tech demo out of a ghostly mansion and then have it star Luigi may be a question for the ages, but 12 years later we are here with its sequel, Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon for the 3DS.

It’s been a decade since I played the original Luigi’s Mansion, but I remember it being a charming, if repetitive experience highlighted by Charles Martinet’s incredible voicing of a freaked out Luigi. With the Wii U in seemingly more need of quality software than the 3DS, I’m surprised some tablet-utilizing version of Dark Moon didn’t show up on the console, but the likelihood of me playing the portable version is much higher, so I personally appreciate the 3DS release. Let’s play.

Being a Nintendo game, Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon opens with a long cutscene shot of one of the game’s mansions. Also being a Nintendo game, you cannot skip it. Why Nintendo insists over and over to include terribly lame, boring, and unnecessary opening cutscenes in their Mario games I will never understand. Chances are Peach is going to get kidnapped by a cake, you can include a cutscene when you finally have an original story.

This is followed up by a looooong conversation with Professor E. Gadd, who explains that the ghosts are angry again, or something (by this time I was just slamming on the A button to get to the action). You had better get used to talking to the Professor every 15 minutes or so, however, as the game is broken up into short missions that just cover a small part of a mansion.

I’m finally handed a flashlight and told to head towards the haunted mansion where the Poltergust 5000 is stored. Yes, the ghostbusting device is stored at the ghost-infested house, but luckily for Luigi, just inside the first room. After trying out the different suck techniques using the R trigger, I start clearing rooms of debris and money in search of those nasty ghosts.

But you can’t fight ghosts until you have a strobe light used to shock them temporarily, though that is nearby too. The early ghost battles are a welcome bit of action after walking around sucking up carpets and drapes, but are quite easy. It actually feels a bit like a fishing game, get your ghost in your suck radius and pull back, depleting its “hit points”.

As you complete your primary objective, you’re sent back to Professor E. Gadd’s lab for another conversation, then sent back to the exact same location with maybe a few more rooms available. It’s an odd design choice, forcing you through the same rooms over and over again, but I think it might be a good decision in the long run, as long as the chats with the Professor were minimized (which seems unlikely since he also calls you up to talk every five minutes, too). There’s an annoying side effect to this though: Dark Moon won’t checkpoint during a mission, so once you’ve made significant progress you had better complete the primary objective before turning off the system. Not the end of the world with the 3DS’s design, but one that caught me off guard when I took a break for lunch.

The graphics of the new Luigi’s Mansion look very good on the portable screens, there’s some nice lighting techniques with the flashlight, and the physics engine surprised me with its versatility when using the vacuum. The game is pretty dark though, and I spent about 15 minutes at one point trying to figure out what to do next when the solution was a little rope hanging in the corner of the room. Felt a bit like pixel hunting in a point and click adventure.

Minutes to Action: 15

Would I Keep Playing? Yes, Luigi’s Mansion: Dark Moon is pretty simple fun, but the possibilities in the game excite me. There are definitely pacing issues with the constant chatter by Professor E. Gadd, but all I can hope is that his screentime is reduced as the game goes on.

Luigis Mansion Dark Moon Poltergust 5000

Comments

I feel this still has the

I feel this still has the great game play and attractiveness as in the past. A bit of a no no-brainer but best as such.

"Minutes to Action: 15"

Such a long opening sequence is annoying on a console or PC game, and downright inexcusable on a handheld game, especially if you can't save mid-mission. This seems like a first play session would need a minimum of a half-hour in order to not be forced through the opening again, and for many people's morning bus rides, that's just too long.

I've heard that the game relies on accelerometer controls to the point that it's pretty much unplayable with 3D on (the two features never did play nice together). Is this, in fact, a problem?

Accelerometer

There's a first person mode when you look through cracks in the walls that can respond to the accelerometer to swing the camera, and also when you're using your flashlight and/or vacuuming, but it's not necessary to use at all, from what I could tell. I could still move Luigi's eyes around with the circle pad.

I also didn't use the 3D much because it made me a tad sick. I was playing on my brother in-law's 3DS so I'm not totally used to the system and experience yet.

Professor E. Gadd earns his name

I'm at the second mansion now, and it's still very enjoyable. I do agree with you on Professor E. Gadd, as he is very tiresome and too talky, and I dislike that he literally warps you back to his HQ when he says so, and sometimes I haven't finished exploring a room fully. Sucking up ghosts is fun, especially when you have to attack multiple ones. I played a game of online multiplayer, too, which works surprisingly well. It's basically horde mode with ghosts broken up into levels of a tower.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.