Gratuitous Tank Battles and Expansion: The Western Front

Gratuitous Tank Battles: The Western Front
Gratuitous Tank Battles Western Front Cover
Platforms Windows
Genre Tower Rush
Buy from Developer

Gratuitous Tank Battles is a unique take on tower-strategy mechanics, created by a man who clearly has a strong attention to detail. This article will be covering both the base game, released this past May, and its expansion The Western Front, which is being released this today on Steam. Both are developed by Positech Games, which is more or less known as Cliff "cliffski" Harris. At first glance, GTB appears to be a standard tower defense game covered in a fine finish, but things quickly become more complicated. For a bit of background reading, we do also have a preview of the game which goes over the basics from a different point of view.

When the player starts the game and passes through the tutorial pop-ups, you head to the "Battle Browser" to begin a conflict. This browser shows the current campaign map and missions along with custom levels and online community challenges. The campaign mode is a semi-branching series of missions to complete, with the optional paths generally containing maps with some sort of gimmick. For example, we're given particularly infantry-heavy battles, and night maps with toggleable low-light vision. Most of the normal maps have a standard 2-4 paths to defend and a fairly decent amount of tower placement locations. The original GTB campaign has eight pre-set maps, with five mandatory and three optional. We're fighting battles from the UK perspective in an alternate universe where World War 1 has lasted 200 years. This campaign has little to no story to speak of, but each level opens and ends with a bit of "inspirational" flavor text. Since that's about all we know about this world, the lack of any flowing story makes the campaign feel more like a sequence of random fights rather than a strong goal-oriented task.

Gratuitous Tank Battles Flavor Text Closeup

The battles themselves are by far the most interesting part of the game, largely because of how Cliff refuses to follow tradition and takes several significant diversions from standard tower defense. Let's make a brief list.

  • Defending and attacking: GTB is created to fully accomodate both player attacking and defending on each map, and towers take damage as well. The give-and-take makes it more difficult to create an overwhelming, static defense. This is why I consider this more of a "tower rush" title.
  • Scripted battles and adaptive AI: On defense, you can fight again a preset attacker run or choose to play versus an adaptive AI that tries to counter you. On offense, you can only choose to play against an AI defense. Your personal runs can be saved and uploaded for your friends or the public to battle.
  • Extremely customizable: As you play campaign, you unlock base towers/units and individual parts for each, with the ability to create your own towers and units for use in any mode. In fact, nearly the entire game is focused around player creation rather than the base experience.
  • A sense of blindness, especially on defense: You have no idea which units will be attacking, you don't know their initial paths choices, you don't have a concrete representation of their hit points, and towers can take a while to build, so it's difficult to react. Very stressful. This blindness is likely implemented to promote a sense of "fog of war," I imagine you'd often have better military intelligence during a real-life ground scenario anyway.
  • No "mazing" or movement manipulation along with limited tower positions: Many TD games don't allow creation of mazes anymore, but GTB can often be strict in limiting tower locations as well.
  • Addition of infantry: Playing defense becomes much more interesting by use of infantry, which you can drop separately in bunkers and trenches around the map. Unlike towers, they become active immediately and are relatively protected by most forms of damage outside of rapidfire weaponry. If they can stay up, they're often a good use of supplies, but generally need some sort of protection. Overall, infantry is a strong unique element of risk/reward and an important layer to defense. On offense, they're somewhat less interesting and more risky due to dropping supplies in form of dogtags.
Gratuitous Tank Battles Desert Mess Cover

Like many players (I'd assume), my initial playthrough was by shoehorning the game into traditional tower defense settings; playing on defense versus scripted units. After some rough patches early, I began to "cheat" and checked the first wave of attacking movements before I started laying towers. Often times you had two possible attacker paths on completely different sides of the screen, and only one was active at the start, making it near-impossible to react and form a full defense in time. This felt fairly cheap, so I resorted in kind by checking the scripted movements beforehand and restarting the map. I also turned game speed down to .4x or .6x on my initial runthrough, as that gives you much more time to react and properly defend multiple paths. In my opinion, the default game speed should probably be ~.5x for first-time players (note: I resolved my issue with speed - keep reading). After that, I mostly held to a solid plan of heavy + gatling towers in front, surrounded up by missile towers everywhere. Tower repair and rapid-fire support should be used in every possible slot. A lot of people seem to have difficulty working through the game, but this strategy worked well. Considering I completely and unintentionally ignored dogtags supplies from downed infantry units until most of the way through both campaigns, I'd say that the difficulty isn't too unreasonable. If anything, missiles may be a bit overpowered if they're put in a position to succeed with support buildings and anti-infantry help. This game has a rock-paper-scissors system of lasers, ballistics, and rapid guns (against shields, armor, and infantry), but you only really need to counter properly in the first wave or two if everything goes well, before you have a larger defense in place. To give an example of the gameplay, here's a video of one of the Western Front missions. Unfortunately, this map is particularly unfriendly to defensive infantry, both because of bunker placement and swarms of machine gun vehicles.

Presentation of the game is surprisingly strong for such a small team. Pre-match visuals and sound mesh perfectly to create a retro war feel, and the battle production is smooth as well, with strong effects and massive detail across the board. The game itself generally runs quite well, although it doesn't work correctly at non-standard refresh rates, and this is the cause behind the speed problem I had while playing. Running at 120hz, the battles play out at double speed. The engine seems to be fully attached to the frame count rather than time. Super Meat Boy had the same issue, but limited to certain scripted events. The above video shows the issue part of the time; fraps theoretically allows games to run at an unfettered framerate while recording, but usually holds to 60fps in practice anyway. At some points, the video noticeably speeds up as fraps no longer limits the fps. Aside from this speed problem, GTB runs very well, although some heavy situations slight slowdown can occur by virtue of the game seemingly only using one thread.

So what can The Western Front add to a game already dominated by player customization and content? Well, it adds a new full "World War II" scenario from the US perspective, complete with eight new maps and two scripted battles per maps (both German and American attackers). We naturally also receive new German and American units (eight of each) and a few new unit attachments for customization. Priced at $6 compared to $20 for the main game, I'd say this is a relatively good value, although personally I feel $4 or $5 would be more appealing just from the number standpoint. The issue is that it would be hard to price creation-focused content, although he does has experience at that price point with Gratuitous Space Battles DLC. If a player enjoys this game enough to purchase an expansion, they're likely focused more on the modding aspects, so the price may have to be fairly low to justify a new sale. The new scenarios and maps are fun, but they don't exactly change the game in a terribly meaningful sense. Without any story or unique battle encounters, the player doesn't really find a new experience. Cliff seems to be thinking that enough players will be intrigued by WW2 units and "the ability to equip Tiger tanks with lazers," and he may be right.

Gratuitous Tank Battles Lazers Cover

This is where I wanted to add more about the expansion, but I can't find more words. It adds the WWII scenario with new preset maps and more unit options, but it's the same experience, so that's about all I can say. Let's just sum things up. Gratuitous Tank Battles is a surprisingly deep "tower rush" game with excellent production values and nearly unmatched customization. Its unique take on genre mechanics are refreshing and a sign of a creator willing to take risks and reach in attempt for greatness. Unfortunately, like similar titles, it seems to be too caught up in certain parts to make a genuinely complete game. Like say, inMomentum, Sanctum, and many bare TD titles, GTB makes not even a small attempt at story or sense of urgency towards pushing the player towards a conclusion. As a result, the game loses its aim as a series of random levels and becomes instantly forgettable as a complete experience. You don't need full production like Anomaly or the depth of character story in Immortal Defense, but most players need at least something more to latch onto for a full game to be truly relevant. With a built-in campaign structure, I would have expected more. In fact, I didn't even see any credit sequence after completing the levels, although my game did hang while connecting to the server (again, that works as a conclusion, and I'd imagine others had some hand in creation of music and art at the least, even if Cliff didn't feel the need to promote himself in credit form).

Despite complaints, I do think the game is very well made and and impressive accomplishment. GTB is a good evolution of the tower rush concept and Cliffski proves a very capable developer of his studio, even including its own encapulated online system. The Western Front adds more gameplay time and grants the user more playable options. But I just wish GTB had slightly different priorities to become a more complete title and be more responsive to gamers as a whole rather than focusing almost entirely on the customization community.

Comments

(No subject)

wq
I am at ray ban occhiali work and this patriots jerseys is vans shoes rushed.
Some covenants chicago bulls jersey are in ferragamo shoes fact not breakable.
The ray ban zonnebril covenant dsquared2 concerning cheap basketball shoes the ralph lauren outlet rainbow is one hermes sided, hogan made nike mercurial vapor by mcm backpack God with mankind. It is one rayban sided cheap nba jerseys not able to coach outlet canada be altered.
What is ray ban sonnenbrillen declared at barbour factory Adam and Eve’s marriage oakley sunglasses outlet is also adidas superstar a one omega watches sided roshe run covenant. God michael kors outlet online decreed ferragamo shoes what nike.se the reality of guciheaven shoes the situation ray bans is concerning nike free 5.0 marriage. He made them heat jerseys male air max and female barbour outlet and he decrees true religion jeans upon michael kors outlet the man’s leaving and uggs outlet cleaving ray-ban sunglasses with katespade his wife that thay juicy couture handbags are swarovski henceforth lunette ray ban one flesh. Jesus knockoff handbags applied adidas online that situation with Adam tommy hilfiger outlet and Eve coach factory as what reebok applies to all hermes bags subsequent lawful tory burch marriages. detroit pistons Notice that ray ban outlet Adam free running and rams jerseys Eve’s asics marriage represents two nike shop people lunette ray ban never michael kors purses married before joining lakers jerseys in swarovski jewelry marriage prada outlet making ray ban their status as one flesh unbreakable.
‘Til ferragamo shoes uk death do prada outlet us part’ michael kors taschen does coach outlet in new york knicks fact timberland femme correctly reflect the jimmy choo shoes truth memphis grizzlies jersey of true religion the decree God has swarovski online made over soccer shoes marriage. Like pandora the nike roshe decree burberry outlet store concerning ralph lauren polo the nike shoes rainbow, it stands glasses frames without coach factory outlet negotiation. michael kors Only golden state warriors jersey death terminates bengals jerseys a www.tommyhilfiger.nl lawful vikings jerseys marriage. new balance canada If it is burberry outlet online assumed that a dansko outlet divorce certificate can terminate it, coach store the mont blanc person’s charlotte hornets jerseys so michael kors assuming the north face outlet that are rudely awakened to the north face jackets fact that nfl jerseys remarriage converse chucks is purses and handbags adultery, coach outlet clearly identifying the jimmy choo outlet divorce as hogan outlet having soccer shoes outlet done versace outlet online nothing concerning nba jerseys their steelers jerseys actual oakley sungalsses outlet staus before oakley canada God. tory burch outlet They mcm handbags are still husband and wife, one nike outlet flesh.I burberry online shop am tommy hilfiger at air huarache work philipp plein outlet and adidas canada this fitflop outlet is ecco outlet rushed.
Some cheap oakley covenants are burberry sale in indiana pacers jersey fact air max schoenen not breakable.
The ralph lauren outlet online covenant michael kors concerning nike free run the polo ralph rainbow guess factory outlet is one sided, baseball jerseys made by coach outlet God with mankind. It fred perry outlet is fivefingers one cheap ray ban sided north face not boots on sale able to be sacramento kings jersey altered.
What is true religion outlet declared woolrich outlet at fred perry polos Adam and Eve’s nike roshe marriage is nike store also puma online a los angeles clippers jersey one veneta sided mizuno wave covenant. polo ralph lauren outlet online God decreed what coach outlet online the reality of air jordan shoes the situation is concerning jack wolfskin outlet marriage. skechers He made eagles jerseys them male parajumpers and tommy hilfiger outlet stores female and he handbags outlet decrees ralph lauren factory store upon supra footwear the portland trail blazers jersey man’s leaving and houston rockets jerseys cleaving with his redskins jerseys wife plein shoes that colts jerseys thay ralph lauren outlet online are henceforth nike air max shoes one flesh. Jesus chiefs jerseys applied nike roshe that reloj situation converse sneakers with Adam michael kors bags and links of london outlet Eve nike tn as baseball jerseys what true religion jeans women applies to all huarache subsequent lawful marriages. new balance Notice that Adam bcbg max and adidas superstar Eve’s philadelphia 76ers jerseys marriage represents ferragamo two ralph lauren outlet people the north face never broncos jerseys married before joining michael kors outlet in marriage mbt shoes outlet making their jerseys from china status as michael kors bags one flesh ray bans outlet unbreakable.
‘Til ugg boots death adidas.se do us replica watches part’ adidas does pandora bracelet in dsquared2 sale fact correctly reflect the raiders jerseys truth of burberry outlet online the hermes belt decree supra footwear God pandora charms has ralph lauren made air max over boston celtics jersey marriage. armani outlet Like the decree concerning nike huarache the ralph lauren outlet rainbow, it polo ralph lauren stands michael kors outlet online without negotiation. bottega veneta Only oakley vault death pandora schmuck terminates washington wizards jersey a north face lawful coach outlet online marriage. If christian louboutin shoes it is assumed roshe run that nike.dk a vans divorce dre beats certificate can terminate it, cc beanies the person’s baseball jerseys so oakley assuming that packers jerseys are chargers jerseys rudely awakened to ralph lauren outlet the ralph lauren outlet fact new balance that ralph lauren polos remarriage is adultery, nike free 5.0 clearly fidget spinner outlet identifying the dallas mavericks jerseys divorce as fossil uhren having polo outlet store done nothing concerning their actual burberry outlet staus before vans schuhe God. They are salvatore ferragamo still michael kors outlet online sale husband thomas sabo and michael kors wife, rolex one titans jerseys flesh.I am at bills jerseys work and cheap nfl jerseys this longchamp outlet is rushed.
Some covenants are in fact not breakable.
The nike air max covenant oakley sunglasses concerning the giuseppe shoes rainbow kate spade outlet online is one san antonio spurs jerseys sided, made hugo boss shop by God atlanta hawks jerseys with mankind. asics gel It is cowboys jerseys one sided mizuno running not jerseys from china able to be air jordan retro altered.
What barbour jackets is burberry handbags declared at mcm backpack Adam ray ban wayfarer and roshe run Eve’s panthers jerseys marriage air jordan is denver nuggets jerseys also a one sided iphone 5s cases covenant. God beats headphones decreed giants jerseys what the reality barbour outlet of adidas online the situation is michael kors canada concerning marriage. He made them puma outlet male chrome hearts and female and he decrees upon jerseys from china the man’s leaving dolphins jerseys and cleaving babyliss pro with jack wolfskin jackets his wife oakley sunglasses outlet that thay are henceforth one fendi handbags flesh. Jesus applied indoor soccer shoes that phoenix suns jersey situation burberry outlet with ralph lauren Adam michael kors and Eve as what nike air max 90 applies to nike shoes all thomas sabo jewellery subsequent lawful marriages. polo ralph lauren outlet Notice that under armour Adam mcm backpack outlet and Eve’s marriage north face outlet represents nike schoenen two jerseys from china people levis jeans never married prada sunglasses before joining nike outlet in marriage tommy hilfiger making hilfiger online shop their status coach outlet online as converse outlet one flesh longchamp unbreakable.
‘Til oklahoma city thunder jersey death do michael kors canada us part’ longchamp outlet does longchamp taschen in nfl jerseys fact correctly cleveland cavaliers reflect the ravens jerseys truth marc by marc jacobs of red bottom shoes the decree God lacoste polos has made timberland boots over marriage. louboutin shoes Like tory burch shoes the valentino outlet decree milwaukee bucks jersey concerning the north face the rainbow, it burberry sale stands without the north face negotiation. stephen curry shoes Only michael kors v?skor death moncler mens jackets terminates minnesota timberwolves jersey a lawful lacoste shoes marriage. If it is assumed rayban that skechers a divorce nike air max certificate beats by dre can red bottoms terminate it, the person’s pandora so juicy couture outlet assuming oakley frogskins that cheap nfl jerseys are rudely awakened to the air max fact michael kors outlet that remarriage is ray ban sunglasses adultery, 49ers jerseys clearly identifying tods outlet the jets jerseys divorce as oakley sunglasses having michael kors outlet online done nothing new orleans pelicans jersey concerning their cheap michael kors actual pandora charms staus belstaff outlet online before ray bans God. coach outlet online They are still husband air max and azcardinals jerseys wife, jordans one flesh.I guess outlet am new balance at marc by marc jacobs work and michael jordan this northface is texans jerseys rushed.
Some rolex watches covenants glasses online are in fact not nike air max breakable.
The covenant nike air jordan concerning nike schuhe the hogan outlet rainbow is toronto raptors jersey one asics outlet sided, made coach black friday by God with givenchy outlet mankind. cheap nba jerseys It is tory burch one ed hardy clothing sided not stone island polos able to coach outlet online be swarovski crystal altered.
What baseball bats is declared at true religion jeans outlet Adam air yeezy shoes and browns jerseys Eve’s marriage is also a converse shoes one sided covenant. God decreed oakley sunglasses cheap what louboutin shoes the zapatillas nike reality of the michael kors uk situation orlando magic jersey is concerning marriage. reebok shoes outlet He nike free 5.0 made them male ralph lauren and saints jerseys female adidas superstar and he decrees upon the coach factory outlet man’s buccaneers jerseys leaving skechers outlet and cleaving with pandora canada his bcbg max azria wife falcons jerseys that thay barbour jackets outlet are oakley outlet henceforth swarovski australia one new balance outlet flesh. Jesus brooklyn nets jerseys applied that prada shoes situation with Adam and prada Eve as iphone case what michael kors outlet online applies to all subsequent lawful marriages. moncler outlet online Notice jaguars jerseys that Adam and Eve’s gafas oakley marriage represents air max 2015 two people never married versace outlet online before ralph lauren polos joining in salomon schuhe marriage cheap true religion making their belstaff status thomas sabo uk as one flesh mcm bags unbreakable.
‘Til nike air max death cheap oakley do coach factory us part’ calvin klein underwear does in ralph lauren fact katespade correctly reflect Sac Hermes the truth of the decree God bears jerseys has timberland shoes made under armour shoes over nike air max thea marriage. Like jordan release dates 2015 the timberland outlet decree lions jerseys concerning polo ralph the rainbow, it stands without negotiation. Only coach purses outlet online death burberry terminates giuseppe zanotti sneakers a kate spade outlet online lawful longchamp handbags marriage. seahawks jerseys If it nike air force is assumed that montblanc a divorce certificate can terminate it, cheap michael kors the person’s oakley so assuming that are rudely awakened to the fact that burberry outlet online remarriage utah jazz jersey is adultery, clearly identifying the nike air max divorce as louboutin having burberry sale done chi hair nothing christian louboutin shoes concerning jordan retro their belstaff outlet actual oakley sunglasses staus before swarovski jewelry God. They are vans outlet still tommy hilfiger online husband and christian louboutin shoes wife, one flesh.

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.